One of many reviewer’s issues is that publication regarded “my” etc given that determiners, after they was indeed in reality (in his viewpoint) pronouns
– I really do agree with your regarding the remaining terms and conditions to a minimum in the training, and i also grant your you to definitely pupils are much gonna understand exactly what adjectives is than determiners.
Indeed, I do believe I recently make reference to “my”etcetera while the possessives in the event your need pops up, hence is not that usually (they don’t apparently lead to many problems for Polish students, at the least). However, direction guides from time to time relate to determiners, thus i need to be able to define her or him.
The point I became and come up with so you can Syed Usman are that it is unsafe to talk when you look at the absolutes inside the vocabulary. Just because their words neighborhood and you may exploit consider “my” etc since the determiners and you will “mine” etc given that “possessive pronouns” this doesn’t mean that a person more speaking about “my” etcetera since possessive pronouns try fundamentally incorrect. Which is definitely just how many linguists relate to them, such as for instance.
We read so it the difficult means. I experienced only authored an article to own my personal blog for the determiners and you will pronouns, once i spotted a very (unfairly in my opinion) poor report about a keen EFL grammar publication towards the a blogs which have a distinctly linguistics angle. As i dared in order to review that the is seriously basic in the EFL, the guy cited Huddleston and you may Pullum in the myself, and i also received an effective lecture regarding “determinatives” (that i had never heard about – neither I do believe, have numerous people).
Once i try rather worried I might first got it every wrong when you look at the my personal blog post, I did so some research for the whole determiner / determinative question (it’s a bit of a mess), which my mention of the both of these resource instructions. But have one to strong idea back at my web log, that’s that we use the mainstream words of EFL, therefore I’m adhering to the high quality EFL and dictionary definition of determiner I’d already put, and you will leaving the fresh weird and you will wonderful content with the linguists..
I concur. In the event the people expected what a great determiner is, I’d merely provide them with an inventory. BTW in the Hungarian, possession is accomplished with noun endings maybe not separate terms and conditions.
In spite of how I think of it, ‘Mine and Greg’s’ is apparently best
Basic, you’ve got the object, the ‘child.’ And after that you feel the a couple possessors, ‘Greg,’ therefore the pronoun for ‘yourself.’ Depending on which person you are composing from inside the, the problem with the procedure varies. Basic body’s dreadful with material possessives!
Take it that have a whole grain out of salt; my ultra-super-chill outpersonals qualifications lay in the of numerous treacherous and unedited areas of Fanfiction; I would not be astonished easily was looking at which completely in reverse!
And, while in question, are saying the new sentence aloud. ‘My and you will Greg’s child’ against ‘Mine and Greg’s child’–what type tunes most readily useful? You realize which one I would fit into. Simply sayin’.
– there lies an element of the condition: it is unclear independent of if i explore ‘my’ otherwise ‘mine’. (We observe that inside my basic opinion I experienced assumed they was speaking of one guy,however, towards next look I’d really consider one or two have been are known.
In addition to this it appears in my opinion unnatural having explanations I pointed out earlier. Anyone got already removed the kid/children to school, very presumably know their term(s) – so why not use only the names in lieu of that it slightly shameful build?
In addition I can not agree with Ashley:) – as far as i know, we virtually avoid using possessive pronouns before individual otherwise material could have been said (except perhaps in-book headings). “Greg’s man and you will mine” could possibly performs, if the here two pupils, or maybe more, but “Mine and you will Greg’s kid”? I do believe perhaps not.